Federal Judge Orders Release Of Dataset Showing Drug Industry's Role In Opioid Crisis

Jul 17, 2019
Originally published on July 17, 2019 10:57 am

Updated at 10:44 p.m. ET

For the first time, a federal court in Ohio is releasing a trove of data that offers far more detail about the size and scope of the nation's opioid epidemic — and about the role played by drug companies and pharmacies like CVS, Walgreens and Johnson & Johnson that profited from the rapid growth of prescription opioid sales.

"I don't think America truly understands the scope and depth, the level of penetration these pills had in their communities," says Paul Farrell with the firm Greene, Ketchum, Farrell, Bailey & Tweel. "It's going to be an awakening."

Farrell is one of three co-lead attorneys suing the pharmaceutical industry as part of the largest consolidated civil lawsuit related to drug industry's role in the opioid epidemic in the U.S., scheduled to go to trial in October.

Some drug companies fought in court to keep the information secret, arguing that it contains proprietary details about their business practices. The U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration also resisted releasing the data, arguing that it included sensitive information used by law enforcement.

But a large portion of the searchable database, known as ARCOS, is set to be released in an order signed by Judge Dan Polster on Monday. Once available to the public later this week, it will offer a transaction-by-transaction account of how opioid pain pills were made, distributed and sold by pharmacy chains from 2006 through 2012 when the addiction epidemic was growing fast.

The data also shows exactly which communities around the U.S. were hardest hit, as pharmacies began dispensing more and more highly addictive medications.

The Washington Post and HD Media, publisher of the Charleston Gazette-Mail of West Virginia pushed for a year for the database to be made public.

Polster is overseeing the consolidated lawsuit in Ohio involving more than 1,200 local governments suing 23 of the biggest firms in the drug industry, ranging from drug manufacturers like Purdue Pharma to wholesale distributors including McKesson and Cardinal Health.

Also named in the suit are retail pharmacy chains such as CVS and Walgreens.

While much of the media scrutiny and recent high profile lawsuits have highlighted how drug manufacturers allegedly fueled the epidemic, the ARCOS data is expected to clarify the role played by distributors and pharmacies.

"You'll be able to see the flow, the steady flow of pills — it's not a trickle, it's a tsunami," Farrell says.

"In my hometown of Huntington, W.Va., there are 24 CVS pharmacies within 40 miles of my house. From those 24 pharmacies, you'll be able to see that 80 million [opioid] pills were distributed [over a six year period]."

The population in that region of the Ohio River valley is roughly 100,000 people.

The data-sets began to be reported by the drug industry — manufacturers, distributors and pharmacies — beginning in 2006. They were compiled by the DEA.

Judge Polster declined to immediately release data to the public collected after 2012 because of concerns raised by the DEA that it could interfere with on-going criminal investigations.

In court documents last year, Polster described the data as "extremely informative," adding that the transaction records reveal "the precise number of opioid pills delivered to each city and county in America, partitioned by manufacturer and distributor and pharmacy."

Mike DeAngelis, a spokesman for CVS, one of the nation's biggest pharmacy chains, declined NPR's request for an interview, citing ongoing litigation.

But the company issued a statement saying that the pharmacy chain is "committed to the highest standards of ethics and business practices" and "dedicated to helping reduce prescription drug abuse and diversion."

NPR reached out to an attorney representing other pharmacies targeted in the consolidated lawsuit, but has yet to receive comment.

More than 1,200 local governments have sued players in the pharmaceutical industry, claiming the industry worsened the opioid epidemic by aggressively marketing and dispensing prescription pain pills while lying about the risks.

Defendants in the case include the nation's largest drugmakers, distributors and pharmacy chains. Despite opioid-related settlements this year totaling nearly $2 billion, most firms have denied any wrong-doing.

"The plaintiffs' allegations about CVS in this matter have no merit and we are aggressively defending against them," CVS' DeAngelis said in his statement to NPR.

More than 200,000 Americans have died from prescription opioid-related overdoses since the epidemic began in the 1990s, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Attorneys suing drug companies say the data now being released paints a troubling new picture of how each sector of the pharmaceutical industry contributed to the crisis.

Copyright 2019 NCPR. To see more, visit NCPR.

NOEL KING, HOST:

A federal court in Ohio is releasing data detailing the opioid epidemic and revealing the role of pharmacies. North Country Public Radio's Brian Mann has that story.

BRIAN MANN, BYLINE: Beginning in 2006, the pharmaceutical industry was required by the Drug Enforcement Administration to collect data on every prescription opioid medication it made, tracking how each pill was distributed, where it was sold, at a local or chain store pharmacy. Until now, that information, known as ARCOS, was kept hidden from the public. But Federal Judge Dan Polster ordered Monday that six years of data be released, covering a period when the drug epidemic was intensifying. Paul Farrell is an attorney suing drugmakers and pharmacies on behalf of local governments. He's seen the ARCOS records.

PAUL FARRELL: I don't think America truly understands the scope or the depth, the level of penetration these pills have in each community. It's going to be an awakening.

MANN: Farrell says he's already been able to compile information about his own community in the Ohio River Valley, hard hit by prescription opioid overdoses.

FARRELL: In my hometown of Huntington, W.Va., there are 24 CVS pharmacies within 40 miles of my house. From of those 24 pharmacies, 80 million pills were distributed.

MANN: Many pharmacy chains, including Walgreens and CVS, deny any wrongdoing. In a statement sent to NPR, CVS spokesman Mike DeAngelis said, allegations about CVS in this matter have no merit, and we are aggressively defending against them. But the wave of litigation has exposed Big Pharma to growing financial risk and to increasingly harsh publicity as court rulings like this one reveal more details about industry practices. Local, state and federal officials say companies earn hundreds of billions of dollars aggressively marketing prescription opioid medications while downplaying or lying about the risk. Brian Mann, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.