Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations
See results and the latest news in the 2026 midterms in OH, KY and IN >>

Just a third of Northeast Ohio school tax increases pass as cost-of-living concerns persist

Parents, students and community members gathered on Pearl Road in front of Strongsville Middle School on Sept. 26 to advocate for a "yes" vote on a school levy.
Sean Balewski
/
For Strongsville levy committee
Parents, students and community members gathered on Pearl Road in front of Strongsville Middle School in September 2026 to advocate for a "yes" vote on a school levy.

School district tax levies across Northeast Ohio fared poorly Tuesday night across Northeast Ohio in an election dominated nationwide by voter concerns over the cost of living.

According to unofficial results, levies in Willoughby-Eastlake and Barberton failed. Both districts said major cuts would be needed if that happened. Barberton is already in a state of fiscal emergency.

Meanwhile, in Tuscarawas County, voters in the Claymont City School District approved a tax decrease for the district, something that was placed on the ballot by citizen initiative.

In total, just a third of Northeast Ohio school districts were successful in getting new taxes passed, according to unofficial results. At the same time, school districts like Painesville, Strongsville, Elyria and Mentor averted major cuts with successful levies.

More than 60 schools had levies on the ballot in Northeast Ohio. About half were renewals of already-voted taxes. The other half were a mix of property tax or income tax increases to fund operations or construction of new school facilities.

School districts across Ohio are facing complex financial challenges. Costs have risen while advocates argue that the state is underfunding schools. Skepticism also abounds in some communities about districts' needs for new funding, after property taxes increased significantly in recent years due to state-mandated reappraisals.

The backlash on property taxes as an overall funding vehicle for schools has been severe. An effort to put an issue on the November 2026 ballot to abolish all property taxes did not succeed, but backers say they're not done. Some school district turned to requests for income tax increases as an alternative, but the vast majority of those proposals appeared to fail Tuesday night. Just two of 14 attempts were successful. Income tax increases also were largely unsuccessful at the ballot in May.

Some schools in Northeast Ohio said stakes were high this election. Strongsville school leaders had said the district would need to cut down to "state minimum" operations, ending middle school sports and a slew of extracurriculars and electives. Those cuts were averted with that levy's passage.

A levy in the Mentor district narrowly passed, averting cuts to dozens of positions. Mentor School Board President Maggie Cook said that amid concerns about affordability among voters, the district asked for less than it had in its last attempt, which failed. She believes that was a factor in its success.

Still, she said, the state must offer relief by addressing school funding.

"We understand that everyone is in a difficult financial situation right now. And that's why the passage of this levy, you know, really just kind of represents their trust and we deeply appreciate it," she said "But we also know that we need to work hard to make sure that the needs of school funding are fixed. This levy is a five-year levy. And we're hoping that after this five years is over, we have a different plan with the state of Ohio with school funding."

School closure decisions were also hanging in the balance this election. Leaders at Painesville and Willoughby-Eastlake schools said they would need to close school buildings if their levies failed. Painesville's levy passed, while Willoughby-Eastlake's failed.

Leaders at school districts like Barberton, Strongsville, Mentor and others say they've already made significant cuts after past levies failed. Barberton schools cut 80 positions earlier this year. The failure of its five-year, 1% income tax levy means the need to cut its budget is even more urgent.

"We are disappointed with the levy outcome, as this result presents significant challenges for the future of the Barberton City Schools and our students," Superintendent Jason Ondrus said in an email to Ideastream.

"The Board of Education will assess the election results to determine future ballot options, while continuing to work directly with the state financial planning and supervision commission to navigate the district's financial planning."

Across the region, school levy renewals fared far better than requests for new money, as usual. Districts reminded voters that their approval would not increase taxes. Not all renewals passed, though. Voters in Garfield Heights and Clearview schools in Lorain County said no to renewals.

Conor Morris is the education reporter for Ideastream Public Media.